Kat vergelijkt een open, overkapte en zelfreinigende kattenbak in een rustige woonkamer

Choosing a litter box: open, covered or self-cleaning?

, by Michael van Wassem, 5 min reading time

Open, covered or self-cleaning: which litter box suits your cat? A practical comparison covering size, placement and common mistakes.

You do not buy a litter box often, but your cat uses it several times a day. A wrong choice shows quickly: a cat that avoids the box, scatters litter or even pees next to it.

The short answer

There is no single best litter box. What matters is that the box is big enough, stands in a quiet place and that your cat likes to use it. An open box is a safe start for most cats. A covered box helps if your cat kicks a lot of litter out or if you want to hide the box in a living space. A self-cleaning box saves scooping, but does not suit every cat and needs extra attention.

The three types side by side

TypeAdvantagesPoints to watch
Open litter boxPlenty of room, good overview, easy to cleanMore odour and visible scattered litter
Covered litter boxLess scattering, privacy for cat and homeCan feel stuffy or cramped, odour stays in the hood
Self-cleaning litter boxLess scoopingHigher price, cat needs to get used to it, system maintenance

Open litter box: simple and clear

An open box gives your cat the most room to move and a view of what happens nearby. Many cats like that. You also see at once how clean the box is and when to scoop. The downside is litter that goes over the edge and odours that spread freely. A box with a higher rim or a raised back wall limits scattering.

Covered litter box: privacy and less mess

A hood keeps litter in the box and hides the box from view. Some cats feel safe in it, others find it too dark or too tight. Preferences differ per cat. Check the size of the opening and the height of the hood: your cat must be able to turn around and should not have to duck. Clean the box more often, because odour lingers in an enclosed space.

Self-cleaning litter box: handy, but not for every cat

This type separates clumps automatically. That saves scooping, but there are points to watch:

  • Check whether a minimum weight applies for the cat. The manufacturer states this.
  • Let your cat get used to it calmly, for example first with the system switched off.
  • Keep watching your cat. When you scoop by hand you see how often and how much your cat pees. A change is an important health signal. With an automatic box you can easily miss it, so use the usage counter or the app if there is one.

The right size

Cat welfare guidelines advise a box about one and a half times as long as your cat, measured from nose to base of the tail. Many standard boxes are smaller. If in doubt, choose the larger size. For kittens and older cats a low entry matters, for large cats extra room.

Placement and number of boxes

  • Put the box in a quiet, easy-to-reach place, not next to food and water.
  • The rule of thumb from the guidelines: one box per cat, plus one extra.
  • With several cats, spread the boxes over different places so one cat cannot block access.
  • Choose a litter your cat likes. Stay with a familiar type and do not change too quickly.

Common mistakes

  1. Choosing a box that is too small because it fits the corner nicely.
  2. Placing the box where it is noisy or busy.
  3. Too few boxes in a household with several cats.
  4. Changing litter and box at the same time.
  5. Buying a self-cleaning box without a getting-used-to period.
  6. Using strongly scented cleaning products. Warm water and mild soap are usually enough.

Checklist before you buy

  • Is the box about 1.5 times the length of my cat?
  • Can my cat step in and out easily?
  • Does a higher rim suit my cat (scatters litter)?
  • Have I chosen a quiet place?
  • Do I need accessories such as a scoop or mat?

Frequently asked questions

Is a box with a hood better against odour?

Not automatically. A hood holds some odour in, but a box that is cleaned often smells least. Open or covered matters less than how often you scoop.

My cat pees next to the box. Is it the box?

It can be the box, the place or the litter. But it can also be a health problem. If your cat suddenly starts peeing next to the box, see the vet.

How do I help my cat get used to a new box?

Put the new box next to the old one first, with the same litter. Only remove the old one when your cat uses the new one.

Summary

  • No type is best for every cat: look at your cat.
  • Roomy and low to enter matters more than the type.
  • Rule: box about 1.5 times your cat's length, one box per cat plus one.
  • A self-cleaning box needs a getting-used-to period and continued attention.

Conclusion

Start with your cat: size, age and habits. Then choose the type that fits and give your cat time to get used to it. That prevents most litter box problems.

Sources

  • ISFM & AAFP, Feline Environmental Needs Guidelines (Ellis et al., 2013, Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery)

⭐ Add Fidello as a preferred source on Google

Tags


Also worth reading!

Fidello klantenservice

© 2026 Fidello

    • American Express
    • Apple Pay
    • Bancontact
    • BLIK
    • Google Pay
    • iDEAL Wero
    • Klarna
    • Maestro
    • Mastercard
    • MB WAY
    • MobilePay
    • PayPal
    • Shop Pay
    • Union Pay
    • USDC
    • Visa

    Login

    Forgot your password?

    Don't have an account yet?
    Create account